We drove a few hybrid models this week. We focused this week on Toyota - so we tried the Prius and the new Highlander Hybrid. We had mixed reviews on both based upon our goals of fuel efficiency (Marina) and safety (Jim). Following are a few of our thoughts:
Jim: The Prius gets great gas mileage, but when driving in it, I felt a bit like it is a deathtrap on wheels. You’d have to drive the Southern California freeways to get what I mean here. Any one out there that does knows that safety is always a concern when driving on the freeways. Speaking of safety, the crash test ratings are great for the vehicle. However, these crash tests are always measured as a straight on or direct side collision with one object stationary. Accidents don’t happen that way and the laws of physics will definitely be in the favor of a larger vehicle if this Prius gets hit on the road. There’s got to be a safer option out there.
Marina: Yes, it is a smaller car. I happen to think they are cute. And I love what they stand for. Freedom from the gas pump. I like feeling like I am making a strong statement every time I get in my car. The Prius feels like a taller vehicle inside than I imagined. The only thing I really didn’t like was that I felt very vulnerable in the event of a side crash. There’s not much between the occupants of the car and the world outside. I don’t like that. Also, no more trips to the mountains (snowboarding) or oceans (surfing) with this car.
Jim: Now the Highlander Hybrid is a different story for me. It’s safe - all five star crash test ratings except for the passenger side which received a four star crash test rating. It’s a little bulkier. Due to its size, it should survive a crash better, and there are front and side curtain airbags. It would fit our lifestyle, Marina’s interest in fuel efficiency and my goal of safety.
Marina: I liked the way the Highlander Hybrid drove. Very smooth. It has a great feature where I can monitor my fuel efficiency as I drive. The Highlander Hybrid is an SULEV which means it is 90% more fuel efficient than an average vehicle. The Prius has a PZEV rating and it is 95%plus more efficient than an average vehicle. I don’t know how much difference that 5%plus makes. I’m looking that up this week. The Highlander Hybrid does feel safer and it fits our lifestyle. I think we are both interested in the Highlander, but I want to explore all options first.
Until next week -
Jim and Marina, Newly Married and Newly Green, writing for We Can Live Green
